Flooring Insight

Gas vs. Electric Fireplaces for Office Spaces: A Purchasing Comparison

2026-11-10 · Warren Hughes

Why This Comparison Comes Up More Than You'd Think

When your office renovation request includes "a fireplace in the lobby or break room," the conversation usually comes down to gas vs. electric. I've handled facility upgrades for a 120-person company for about six years now, and fireplaces come up more often than you'd expect—especially during cold-weather remodels when someone on the leadership team wants "warmth" in the space.

I'm not a licensed HVAC tech or a gas fitter. So I can't speak to flame aesthetics or heat distribution curves. What I can tell you is how these two options compare on the things purchasing actually cares about: installation logistics, operating costs, remote controls, maintenance, and compliance.

The Comparison Framework

Here's what I'm measuring across both options:

  • Installation complexity — what trades need to be involved, and how disruptive it is
  • Operating cost — rough annual expense for typical office use
  • Remote and automation — can facilities control it without a site visit
  • Maintenance — what's the annual upkeep burden
  • Compliance and safety — code requirements for commercial spaces

Quick context before we dive in: I've spec'd both types, most recently a Valor gas insert for our executive break room and an electric unit for a smaller conference room. Both worked fine—for different reasons.

Dimension 1: Installation and Infrastructure

Gas fireplaces need a gas line, ventilation (direct-vent or B-vent depending on the unit), and licensed trades. When we put in the Valor gas insert back in 2022, the project involved a plumber, a gas fitter, and an electrician for the ignition circuit. We also had to order a wiring bundle our supplier called a "valor cable machine" kit—basically the harness and cable assembly for the electronic ignition. Lead time was about six weeks from order to final inspection.

Electric fireplaces run on 120V or 240V, no gas line, no venting required (most are ventless). Installation is simpler. We ordered an electric insert for a conference room and our facilities guy had it running in an afternoon. Trade-off: you need enough electrical capacity on that circuit. Check that before you order.

Comparison conclusion: Electric wins on installation speed and complexity. Gas wins if you need real heat output in a larger space. If your office has a sliding glass door near the fireplace area—say, a patio door—you'll also need to think about how to secure sliding doors in a way that doesn't interfere with the unit. (We had to add a secondary lock and a bar to our break room patio door after the renovation, just as a security baseline.)

Dimension 2: Operating Cost and Heat Output

This is where the math gets real. Gas is usually cheaper per BTU where natural gas is available. Electric is cheaper to install but more expensive to run, especially if you're using it as a primary heat source.

For our space, we're using the fireplace for ambiance more than actual heating. So the operating cost difference is small—maybe $300–500 annually. If you're heating a large room, gas will almost always win on operating cost.

But here's what vendors won't tell you: most office fireplaces are sized based on looks, not heat output. If your facilities team expects to turn down the thermostat when the fireplace is on, that's probably not going to work unless you've specifically sized the unit for heating. Most of what I've seen in office installations is decorative.

Dimension 3: Remote Controls and Automation

Both types have remote options, but they're different. A valor fireplace remote (and similar gas fireplace remotes) usually controls flame height and on/off function. Electric fireplaces often come with a basic remote included, or you can use a wall switch.

Here's where I'd compare this to other facility equipment: if you've ever managed a Liftmaster garage door opener, you know what good automation looks like. The fireplace remote isn't there yet. Most of them are basic RF remotes. Some newer models have app control, but commercial-grade app integration is still spotty.

Comparison conclusion: Electric has the edge on simplicity—you can plug it into a smart outlet or wall switch. Gas remotes work, but don't expect garage-door-level reliability. Test the remote before you buy. And keep the manual somewhere the facilities team can find it. We learned that the hard way when someone lost the remote for three weeks.

Dimension 4: Maintenance

Gas: Annual inspection recommended. Clean the glass, check for leaks, replace batteries in the ignition. Budget $150–250 per year for a service contract.

Electric: Almost zero maintenance. Wipe down the glass, vacuum behind the unit occasionally. No service call needed unless something breaks.

Comparison conclusion: Electric is easier. This matters if your facilities team is stretched thin—and most are. Also, if you have shower facilities in the office (and yes, I've had employees ask about shower shoes for the gym locker room—that's a whole other procurement conversation), the humidity can affect gas units more. Electric is more forgiving in damp environments.

Dimension 5: Compliance and Safety

This is the one I care about most, because compliance issues are what keep me up at night.

Gas: Commercial installation usually requires a permit and inspection. Venting requirements are strict. You'll need to verify clearance to combustibles. If your office has a gas line, fine. If not, the cost to run one can be significant.

Electric: Simpler from a code standpoint. No venting, no gas line. Just verify the circuit can handle the load. Most units come with a standard plug.

Per FTC advertising guidelines, any energy-efficiency or cost-savings claims you see from vendors need to be substantiated. So when a salesperson tells you "this gas fireplace cuts your heating bill by 40%," ask for the data. In my experience, those numbers come from controlled lab tests, not real office environments.

Comparison conclusion: Electric is easier on compliance. Gas is manageable if you have the infrastructure and a good contractor.

Which Should You Pick?

Here's my honest take—and I say this as someone who's bought both:

Choose gas if:

  • You have an existing gas line near the installation point
  • You need actual heat output in a large space (think 500+ sq ft)
  • Your facilities team is comfortable with annual maintenance
  • You want the look and feel of a real flame (and budget allows for the higher install cost)

Choose electric if:

  • Installation speed and simplicity matter
  • You're using it for ambiance, not primary heating
  • Your electrical panel has capacity
  • You want minimal maintenance and remote control simplicity

Neither is clearly better. I've seen gas installations that looked fantastic and worked flawlessly for years. I've also seen electric units that employees loved just as much—and that cost a fraction to install. The right choice depends on your building's infrastructure and how the space will actually be used.

One more thing: if your renovation includes adjacent areas—say, a garage entry with a Liftmaster opener, or a patio with sliding doors—plan the control wiring and security around all of it at once. We didn't, and ended up retrofitting a lock for the sliding door and re-routing a remote sensor after the fireplace was already in. That added about $800 and a week of coordination. Learn from my mistake.

Bottom line: don't let a vendor talk you into one option because "it's better." Ask what your building supports, ask what the space is actually used for, and ask what maintenance looks like in year three. That'll tell you more than any spec sheet.

Share LinkedIn Email
Warren Hughes
Warren Hughes

Warren Hughes is a building-envelope analyst specializing in windows, exterior doors, siding, cladding, architectural glass, curtain walls, storefronts, anchors, gaskets, and perimeter seals. He applies ASTM E283/E283M, ASTM E330/E330M, and ASTM E331 to their respective air-leakage, structural, and water-penetration evaluations while tracking pressure differential, deflection, leakage rate, drainage, glass make-up, and anchorage. His field-oriented guides help architects, façade contractors, and developers define mock-up tests, interface details, acceptance limits, and remedial priorities before enclosure closeout.